Red Tomato Pizzeria Llc

haven't been back in over a decade and this pizza still stands up next to sally's in new haven as my favorite pizza. the crust is as thin and crispy, without sacrificing any structural integrity to hold up whilst eating, with the perfect amount of chew that deteriorates with a perfect mini burned spots that just burst the umami of the sauce as you eat it. nice to know that something that set such an impression on me when i lived a stones throw away throughout high school hasn't changed at all. also i don't remember them having baklava 15 years ago but needless to say it was masterfully made and i would implore anyone with a sweet tooth to try it, it's not overly moist like some baklava and the nuts were evenly spread making for a nice bite every time.

This has always been my Favorite Pizza on the Shoreline. Worth the Drive--although they don't deliver. BEST pizza sauce & crust-Ever. Their crust has a taste like no other! Dined-in recently for lunch after a few yrs of only doing Pick-up; Service was quick! Younger Waiter/Cook was super nice. I ordered lasagna & a white clams casino pizza, which I now know a white pie is also great. ☆If you haven't been, you must try!

Small place with great feel. We liked the place, it feels small but cozy. Pie is good, crust thin and toasty with the right burnt. flavors were on point. We also had the wings and liked them a lot as well. Service is quick and friendly. Tried a bottle of wine that had a great price and we liked it. Will be Back.

3.75 stars. Good pizza. Not great, but, by New Haven-area standards (VERY high), this was totally enjoyable for what it was. I'd order it again if I didn't have time to hit up one of the heavy hitters closer to New Haven city center (Modern, Zuppardi's, Da Legna, and, on a good day Frank e Pepe -sadly Sally's new money-grubbing owners' are ruining that fine establishment's pizzas, especially the sauce). When in Madison, go here (and get toppings on your pizza. They make the pies that much better). ;-)