Amici Madison

This place was a major surprise while Intown for biz in this small town Of Madison! I walked in and the place was packed Saturday night and the manager Dave seated me exactly where i wanted to sit and the waitress Morgan was excellent service and the food was outstanding! the house salad was above and beyond expectations and the pizza was delicious! The live music was a 90s cover band that killed it and their name is Monkey Wrench. Highly recommend this little gem in the small town of Madison.

American food served in a rustic interior with their own beers as well as others from the area. Staff like Mary Beth make going out for dinner worth it. Visiting in the area, the food took a long time to say the least. MB acted to ensure my food was getting prepared and made a joke to ease my unpleasant expression. The food was good but the service was top notch. Nothing tops good service especially when the kitchen falls short.

We arrived pretty late after flight delays, but was promptly seated and drinks ordered. Just after receiving our food, It was obvious that the staff was cleaning up in preparation for closing. Food was fantastic, waitress was attentive, and never did they make us feel rushed to leave. Amici made a great first impression!

Our to go order was awful tonight. We ordered chicken parm sub and chicken parm pasta dish. Both were burnt - black on the edges. Spaghetti was not really good either. The lemon pepper wings were ok, but we had to add some hot sauce to make it better. They forgot our fries. The Caesar salads were delicious.

This used to be our favorite place to eat in town. However we haven't had a chance to eat here in months due to the 1-2 hour wait to be seated. We finally got in at a decent time the other night looking forward to the good food and great service. What we experienced instead was an hour wait to get appetizers. Followed by another hour and a half wait for our meals as we watched other tables around us be seated, served, finish their meals and leave. When our food did arrive my wife and I bit into cold food. Her wings were not tossed and were covered in sweet sauce, not extra spicy. My calzone was buffalo chicken, not BBQ chicken that I ordered. Our two friends' Alfredo dishes were separated.

If I could give it less then one star I would. Walk in at 6pm, get seated immediately. Wait 20 minutes and not one soul stops at our table to ask us anything. As we wait multiple other tables come in and are seated and served drinks, appetizers. An embarrassment of an establishment. Can't blame.short staff either because had multiple hostesses and servers. Terrible. Train your people or fire them.