Bottle Hill Tavern

We called ahead to reserve a table of 10 with a person with a wheel chair. The table was very narrow and seating was very close, but we managed to sqeeze in. I enjoyed the deviled egg appetizer that was sprinkled with bacon bits. The popcorn shrimp was not the small sized ones that were expected. Only 4 large shrimp came to an order so we had to order 2. The fried okra and potato skins were enjoyed too. Our guests loved their burgers, pulled pork, chipped beef and salmon salad. I am sorry to say that I was disappointed in my dry herb chicken breast and overly charred grilled vegetables. Service was excellent. The place was very busy on a Wednesday night. It is bright and tight (with spacing of tables). There is no dedicated lot, so you have to find parking on the nearby streets.

Bottle Hill Tavern is a great restaurant in Madison! The service was amazing. Our server, Ann Marie, was so sweet and attentive! I was also really impressed that one of the restaurant managers brought me a chair with a back for their high top table because I have a bad back. The food was incredible. The blackened salmon added to the Power Bowl was one of the best salads I've had from a tavern style restaurant.

We were passing through Madison decided to give this place a try . First let me start by saying the prices are great!! The Cuban sandwich was awesome , Brussel sprouts awesome and fries awesome! The atmosphere was great , I can’t wait to come back to this place. I wish I found out about it sooner . Keep doing what your doing !

This is a great spot in Madison. Definitely recommend trying it out. There are a few downsides: 1. They don't take reservations and they are very busy. You usually have to wait for a table. 2. The inside is pretty small especially in the bar area 3. The noise level is quite high and makes it difficult to have a normal conversation with the people sitting at your table. The food and drinks are great, and the pricing is reasonable.

We have been coming here now for over two years for holiday meals (ps- they have these meals every day!)… we tried somewhere else today for Thanksgiving and the food was so bad we ended up not eating it and coming back here! We were happy they could still help us at 2 PM on Thanksgiving. The turkey dinner here is delicious, tender and the gravy is tasty. The stuffing and mashed potatoes are also very tasty but the banana pudding is the best thing they have on the entire menu! We will stick with you now from now on on holidays.