Carl’s Deli

The staff and ordering experience is wonderful! I am updating my review to remove a star, as the sandwich portions (or ratios?) have gotten noticeably smaller in the last year or so at Carl’s, and I no longer feel like most of the menu has a great value as it once did. Everything still tastes amazing with a great selection.

Best sandwiches around, with lots of other fun goodies. My only quibble is that even if you order something that is specifically described as “hot” on the menu, you do have to remind them to toast your sandwich, because if I order a hot sandwich from the menu and don’t specify to toast it, about 75% of the time it won’t get toasted (sad face). Still a 5-star establishment and my go-to for sandwiches.

First time, won’t be our last. The gentleman who rang up our order names the following numbers as the top 4 most popular in his opinion: The Reuben’s (#3 & #8), The Country Club (#23), and The Hot Heidi (#20). He also named The Crab and Artichoke (#6) one of his favorites. That’s what I ordered because I love crab, I love artichoke, and I love croissants - but sadly I didn’t ‘love’ this sandwich…it’s probably just me but the texture sort of put me off to it which was a bummer. I got a few bites in and had to stop. I don’t fault them though, I would just give a heads up to you that it is imitation crab and a pretty slimy sandwich. My husband got the #18 and it was delicious!! We also got a side of their ranch pasta salad, it was okay but I wouldn’t get it again. They have great pickles! Crunchy and delicious! Overall, I’d definitely recommend giving this place a try. We’ll be back to try some more of their sandwiches! A true deli with a massive array of options, I’d be surprised if they didn’t have something everyone loved. Great staff. The menu was a bit overwhelming at first but when I told them it was our first time they were more than helpful and made some great suggestions. They have a fridge with a decent selection of beverages, alcoholic included. They also have ice cream!